Why don't I know what I want?
Share
Have you ever found yourself wondering what you actually want from life?
Perhaps you've spent years doing what was expected of you, fulfilling your responsibilities and meeting the needs of other people – many of us are trained to do this and we don’t even realise we’re doing it.
That was me, and my first clue to recognising this might not be “optimal”, came from my body. Yes, that chronic fatigue crash. But I didn’t immediately recognise that. Now I look back, the first awareness started to drop in when a coach asked me to define my goals. For some reason, that felt like the most triggering question to ask me. I realised I couldn’t really name my goals.
I blamed all sorts of things: indecision, the impact of illness. But then I began to realise something: What if this isn't simply a matter of being indecisive? What if you've become so accustomed to paying attention to other people's needs that you've lost touch with your own? And what if that pattern is actually a protective mechanism?
Let me show you what I mean…
How do we lose touch with our own needs?
Back when I was still trying desperately to manage my energy and navigate life without the constant cycle of “boom and bust”, I met with more than one practitioner who advised me to begin addressing trauma.
This confused me (a lot) because I didn’t think anything in my life had been particularly traumatic…nothing that seemed to have induced PTSD anyway.
What I hadn’t comprehended, because I didn’t know it existed, was that I was carrying a LOT of developmental trauma.
I'm not going to explore developmental trauma in detail here. Instead, I want to focus on one particular aspect that helped me understand why I had become so disconnected from my own needs.
In Laurence Heller’s model of developmental trauma, this is the aspect called “attunement trauma”.
Heller suggests that a healthy adult has developed the capacity to identify and understand their own needs. From that capacity, we then move on to the ability to ask for our needs to be met.
And, if you’ve been reading any of my articles about anger or boundaries, you will be starting to understand why it can be difficult to articulate boundaries if we don’t know who we are.
But how might we reach adulthood without knowing what we actually need?
Our “needs” can cover a vast array of things.
You might be familiar with a model called Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, which suggests we have a basic set of needs that revolve around survival – food, water, shelter. Only once these have been met can we then progress to addressing our needs for love, purpose, and so on.
As tiny children, none of us has capacity to meet our basic survival needs on our own. We are wholly reliant on the adults around us to do this.
In an ideal world, the adults will attune themselves to us and recognise how best to meet our needs. In reality, it’s more likely that we end up adapting to accept what is offered to us and disconnecting from any needs that we cannot get fulfilled.
And I’m not saying this is always a bad thing: we may feel the “need” for sugar, but a caring adult also understands that, in the interests of our long-term health, it is wise to teach us how to curb that need!
So, it seems basically inevitable that we will all reach maturity and have learned to reject, disconnect from, or suppress some things that might also be “needful” for us in some way.
We will have learned to connect our identifiable needs in a way that is socially acceptable. And this may be all that we ever require for a happy, healthy, balanced life. But there is also another possibility…
For those of us who reach a point where we feel like we’re not entirely fulfilled or that the needs that we are meeting don’t seem to offer us meaning, joy or purpose, this can be an invitation to start exploring.
What happens when you become more attuned to others than yourself?
I can recognise this pattern very clearly when I look back at my own experience. Some of us reach adulthood and recognise that we feel pretty lost. Perhaps that has even manifested into health issues (as it did for me). But we aren't necessarily used to considering whether physical symptoms might also be pointing towards emotional needs. So, even if we do recognise we feel lost, we’re not sure why. Particularly if we have ticked all the life boxes and, to the outer world, look as if we are very successful (which was also true for me).
As I explored this struggle with setting goals, the feeling of being lost, my eventual discovery was essentially that I had wandered so far away from my inner compass that the life I had created was barely covering my survival needs, and had no room for my innate soul-needs.
And that was largely because I didn’t know what my soul-needs looked like. I had become so attuned to other people’s requirements of me that I had lost myself. So, it was no good educating me in how to create boundaries or become more autonomous because I didn’t have a sense of who I was and what actually brought me pleasure.
Without that sense – that attunement to “me” – there was little point in defending boundaries because whatever boundaries (sense of self) I had established weren’t really serving my deepest needs anyway.
This was an important distinction for me.
Learning to say no, communicate my needs or maintain boundaries might have been useful skills. But before I could use those skills to create a life that genuinely nourished me, I needed to discover what I actually wanted to say yes to.
And even before we can really get to that point, there is a deeper recognition that we need to make: What if you're no longer a child who has to adapt?
The parts of us that we needed to disconnect from didn’t stop existing. It’s more like they stopped “growing”. So, they remain inside us, but still in their child form, and often they don’t realise that what we needed to do to survive as children is no longer the same as the choices that may be available to us as adults.
To use a small example: As a baby, if someone else doesn’t give me food, I have no capacity to provide it for myself. As an adult, if someone else doesn’t give me food that I like and which nourishes me, I am completely empowered to go and prepare my own food. And yes, you can broaden that and consider “food” as a metaphor for all sorts of nourishment, not only the sustenance we pass through our physical digestive system!
Of course, recognising that we have choices doesn't necessarily make those choices easy to exercise. I needed to begin exploring who I am, what brings me pleasure, what I need. And, in order to even be permitted to start that process, I first had to follow a desperately painful path of letting go of a relationship that was actively blocking me from exploring my needs and desires. As I began to explore, any time I discovered something that brought me joy, but which conflicted with the other person’s needs, I was actively punished. It took some strength to recognise that I am now an adult and no longer need to submit to the punishment of those in authority – I am my own authority. But that is another story for another day.
The point is, once I had extricated myself from that “prison”, I was then free to explore, but where to begin?
How do you begin discovering what you want?
By exploring, I mean asking questions. Contemplating what brings us pleasure as well as allowing us to survive. Trying things and seeing how they feel.
For me, this meant beginning to pay attention to my own experience rather than automatically looking outside myself for the answer.
· What do I actually enjoy?
· What feels nourishing to me?
· What am I choosing because I genuinely want it, and what am I choosing because I've become accustomed to meeting somebody else's expectations?
So, this is a process, not an “event”. Maybe a useful place to begin is to just start noticing your experience of the life you're already living?
You might discover that some things you've always done don't actually bring you much pleasure. You might notice things when you feel unexpectedly energised, interested or joyful. Or perhaps you'll begin recognising preferences that you've never previously given yourself permission to express.
The important thing isn't necessarily to make dramatic changes immediately. It's to begin discovering what is genuinely yours.
What if getting to know yourself is the first step?
If you've spent much of your life adapting to other people, it may take time to recognise the difference between their expectations and your own needs. And sometimes the lines between those things are blurred or nuanced. But that’s OK – this is about a process of exploring to discover or reveal yourself. Perhaps create a new version of what you had previously thought you were.
In my own experience, learning to recognise what genuinely nourishes me has been an essential part of reconnecting with myself. And it has changed the way I understand boundaries, autonomy and personal responsibility.
Rather than asking only, “How do I stop doing what other people want?”, perhaps we can also ask:
“What would I choose if I knew what I truly wanted?”
And if the answer is, “I don't know yet”, that isn’t wrong - it's simply an invitation to begin discovering.
In the next article, I'd like to explore something that has become particularly important in my own journey: the possibility that pleasure and joy can act as a compass, helping us recognise what genuinely nourishes us.